Choosing your care

6 ways to make a nonsurgical treatment trial useful

Trying nonsurgical care should come with a purpose, a practical plan, and a review point. Ask what you are testing, which improvement matters, and what would make the next decision clearer.

Published by Commons Clinic · Updated October 21, 2026 · 4 min read

1. Ask what this trial is intended to answer

A trial of therapy, a brace, activity changes, a medicine, or another approach can serve different purposes. Ask whether the aim is to improve a particular symptom, build function, learn about the source of a problem, or prepare for a later decision. You should know what the team hopes to learn even if the exact response is uncertain. 'We will try this first' becomes more useful when it includes why that first step is appropriate for you.

2. Compare the reasonable options together

AHRQ’s SHARE framework emphasizes comparing benefits and harms and discussing what matters to the patient. Ask which choices apply to your diagnosis and whether there is a reason to favor one now. Include the possibility of continuing the current approach or waiting only if the clinician considers it reasonable. If symptoms or findings make delay a concern, ask what changes the timeline. Nonsurgical care is an individual choice within a clinical plan, not a universal requirement before every operation.

Sources: AHRQ: Essential Steps of Shared Decision Making

3. Turn the recommendation into doable actions

AHRQ’s action-planning guidance recommends specific, manageable steps linked to a goal the patient values. Ask exactly what you should do, how often, with what equipment or support, and who demonstrates it. Name a barrier before it becomes a missed plan: work hours, travel, cost, uncertainty about a movement, or trouble using a brace. If the plan has several parts, ask which are essential first and how to introduce them in a way you can follow.

Tell the team which part of the plan feels least feasible before leaving. A small practical change may make the trial more informative.

Sources: AHRQ: Make Action Plans, Tool 15

4. Agree on what a useful response would look like

Choose a task or symptom to discuss at review, such as a longer walk, easier use of a hand, or fewer interruptions to sleep. Record the starting point without turning the trial into constant self-monitoring. Ask what counts as enough improvement to continue and what a limited response might mean. A treatment may help one goal without helping another; bring both observations to the follow-up. That makes the decision more specific than labeling the entire trial a success or a failure.

AMA informed-consent guidance includes alternatives and the burdens of treatment. A nonsurgical trial deserves that same discussion: what are we hoping to learn, what would count as worthwhile benefit, and what commitment does it require? Ask our clinician how the trial fits your diagnosis and whether delaying a different option carries a concern in your situation. Discuss time, cost, travel, and your ability to follow the plan. The decision is easier to review when the intended purpose is written down before you begin, rather than reconstructed after several visits.

Sources: Informed Consent — AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 2.1.1

5. Know the review point and the earlier-call plan

Ask when you will reassess, who makes that appointment, and which changes should bring you back sooner. If a medicine or injection is included, confirm personal risks and the route for questions about an unexpected response. Do not extend, repeat, or stop a prescribed treatment without discussing the relevant instructions. If the first trial helps only briefly or cannot be carried out, ask what that teaches the team and whether the diagnosis, amount, or approach needs another look.

APTA guidance uses an initial functional baseline and ongoing reassessment to guide a therapy plan. If your treatment trial includes physical therapy, ask which task or measure will be compared at review. Explain the activities you need for work or home and any limits on attending sessions. Agree on what information to bring back and whom to contact if a new concern appears. If the first approach is not helping, ask whether the next decision concerns the diagnosis, the way treatment is delivered, or the choice of another option.

Sources: Documentation: Initial Examination and Evaluation

6. Review the trial before choosing the next step

At the review visit, bring an example of something that improved, something that remained difficult, and anything that made the plan hard to follow. This is more informative than deciding the treatment either worked or failed. If cost, side effects, transport, or caregiving interrupted the trial, say so plainly. The next decision may involve making the plan more practical, reconsidering the diagnosis, or comparing a different option. Agree on the reason for the change before starting again.

Make the most of your visit

Questions to bring to your consultation

Choose the questions that matter most to you. Bring them along, and ask us to explain anything that is unclear.

  • What question is this treatment trial intended to answer?
  • Why is it a reasonable first step for my diagnosis?
  • Which other options should I compare?
  • What exactly should I do, and what support will I need?
  • Which activity or symptom will we use to judge the response?
  • When will we reassess, and who schedules that review?
  • Which changes should make me contact the team earlier?
  • What will we consider if the benefit is limited or short-lived?

Sources & further reading

We use these medical sources to help explain your options and prepare you for a conversation with our team. Our guides feature our own clinicians; patient reviews describe individual experiences.

Read as Markdown

Patient experiences

Meet the clinician.
Hear the experience.

Read how patients describe their care, then bring the questions that matter to your own visit. Each portrait stays with that clinician’s accounts.

Excerpt

She listened carefully to my symptoms and explained what was going on with my knees and the treatment options available.
DS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Allyson Estess, MD

The reviewer shares their experience of care.

Excerpt

Answered all of my questions and gave me various treatment options for my care. A+ - Highly recommend this practice 💯
TF
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Allyson Estess, MD

The reviewer shares their experience of care.

Excerpt

Good Visit, got a great explanation of my options for my knee and would definitely recommend.
OT
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Allyson Estess, MD

The reviewer shares their experience of care.

Excerpt

She was prompt, respectful, with solid knowledge. She was quick to diagnose my condition and gave me very clear options for treatment.
DB
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Allyson Estess, MD

The reviewer shares their experience of care.

Excerpt

A++. Dr. Estess was excellent advising on and tending to my shoulder injury (X-rays, cortisone injection).
JD
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Allyson Estess, MD

The reviewer shares their experience of care.

Excerpt

Dr. Estess took the time to explain everything to my daughter and me and to offer care options.
DS
Read review on Yelp

Allyson Estess, MD

A family member shares their experience of the care provided.

Browse the full review collection

Keep exploring

Your next
good question.

More guidance to help you understand your options and plan your next step.

Meet the clinicians

Explore your
next conversation.