Eric S. Millstein, MD

Shoulder reviews

Page 3 of 4.

Back to these patient experiences →

73 written reviews

Highest rated first · Newest within each rating

Dr. Millstein was great, very friendly and transparent with his thoughts about my shoulder problem. He made me feel very confident that I'll heal soon.
VV
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein initially preformed shoulder surgery on me and we quickly developed a solid relationship. He is at the top of his game as a surgeon, a good listener, family man and responsive to all my inquiries. Subsequently, I have been back for my knee et al.
GY
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Eric Millstein is magical! I saw 5 doctors before going to him for a shoulder replacement. All doctors, including Eric said that the recovery is about 85%. I'm no spring chicken (nearly 70), very active and athletic, riddled with arthritis and I have had a 110% recovery! Yes! I have FULL range of motion. He is brilliant and a masterful technician. I am incomplete awe of him. I couldn't find my last review but that one too was filled with idol worship. I wish he could fix every part of my body that needs fixing!!!!!!!!
MM
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I've been seeing Dr. Millstein for almost 10 years now. Not every day of course. And not every year either. Within those 10 years, there could be stretches of 3 or 4 years where I didn't need to see him at all. However, when I do need to see Dr. Millstein, it's always a stellar experience. The combination of his hip sense of humor along with his superb skill honed over years of practice make for one of the best doctors I've ever had. The 2013 knee surgery and 2016 shoulder replacement were both amazing. Yes, he's not the only doctor who could've done this for me but I can't imagine I could've been in better hands. My visit yesterday was a follow-up. He went over x-rays with me and explained everything in a way that my non-medical brain could comprehend (as he always does). I'm confident every patient of his walks away believing they are his favorite patient. He is simply the best in L.A. Yes, I realize that's a bold statement considering I haven't met every orthopedic surgeon in the city but I stand by it all the same.
S
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Discussed next steps re shoulder. Dr Eric is extremely articulate and explains suggestions in complete detail giving you total confidence. He is just simply outstanding!
BP
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Honesty is what I was looking for I have enough friends I'm not looking for a new one I wanted a surgeon that knows his work and that is professional that calls it like it is. My left shoulder is excellent.
MD
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

This dr is the best i had surjery for my shoulder every thing was good his office worker are kind nice and helpful I am so thanks from this dr and his office last year my knee was so bad and i had alot of pain dr Millstein helped me without surjery now I am 90%beter and again dr Millstein thank you so much.
PN
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein and his entire staff are all fantastic. The organization is a model of how a doctors office should run. Dr Millstein is very pleasant and the way he explained my shoulder injury was so easy to understand. He explained what the next weeks of healing would be like, and calmed down all of my fears about whether my shoulder would return to full function. I have so much confidence in Dr Millstein and I’m very happy I chose to see him.
HA
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

First visit today (painful shoulder injury). Dr. M was prompt, attentive and helpful. Just what I had hoped for. His staff was excellent, from the front to the back--all friendly and eager to please. More than what I had hoped for.
AW
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein has had to put my shoulders back together three times now. He's professional, compassionate and a true expert at what he does. You will not find a better surgeon or person for that matter to help put your body back together. He even did a PRP injection years ago on me for a few hundred dollars when others were charging thousands. I asked him why he would do that for me and he just said "I just want to see you healthy". Great guy and I'm so thankful he's been my surgeon for years.
BH
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is an excellent orthopedic surgeon. I initially saw him for severe arthritis in both of my shoulders. In 8/16, Dr. Millstein performed right shoulder total replacement surgery. My recovery has been excellent. I never thought that I would regain my strength and range of motion to the extent that I have. My physical therapist has consistently remarked that Dr. Millstein's skill is excellent. At each and every visit, Dr. Millstein gave me all the time I needed to have my questions answered. His office staff is excellent and very caring. J. V.
JV
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I had terrible pain in my right should from years of arthritis in my joints. Dr. Milstein performed surgery that replaced my entire shoulder. That was a year ago and I am now pain free. This wonderful doctor has given me a new life! Every day I thank the "powers that be" that sent me to him.
PS
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Found him on Yelp and the rave reviews are well-deserved! Went up on the elevator with two current post-op patients and their opinions of him were very enthusiastic. Went for a third opinion about my shoulder because the first two were so different. He answered all my questions and explained his opinion (no surgery necessary) clearly. Best mix of medical expertise, courtesy and warmth.
LA
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

WOW! I am very impressed with this office. I came in after falling off my bike during a triathlon (on a Sunday) and really hurt my shoulder. We called first thing Monday morning about an appointment that day and we were able to be seen within 2 hours of calling. I was x-rayed and left with the prognosis of a separated shoulder. I then lost my Rx and called the front desk to get another one. They faxed the papers over to me immediately and even emailed them as well to ensure that I received it. Great front desk staff as well as nursing staff. Would recommend to anyone looking a orthopedist!
AK
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I'm not it ANY way associated with Dr. Millstein and his office outside of the many positive experiences with him and the staff. The least I can do is share here. This is my first review. I am a performer with a touring Broadway production. After many non-surgical treatments for an ongoing shoulder injury, it was time for serious intervention. After researching surgeons around the country I landed here in LA and had an appointment with Dr. Millstein. He was not quick to diagnose without first hearing ALL of my questions/concerns. He was very realistic and truthful about my recovery which any athlete/performer appreciates when your livelihood depends on it. It did not take long for me to decide this was the proper route. The front office has been very communicative, polite, professional. Response to any questions I'd have usually were responded to via callback or email the same day. (Not to mention Dr. Millstein called me the night of my surgery to check up!) The nursing staff in the office is amazing as well. They have always been very encouraging, upbeat, and "in tune". None of this feels "put on" or disingenuous. In approximately 6 or 7 appointments I've not waited more than 10 minutes to be placed in a room. Within another 5 minutes a nurse is taking blood pressure, etc. and another 5 Dr. Millstein is there. Something to consider is other patients, like myself, who have 1000 concerns and Dr. Millstein sits, listens, and answers without rushing. We should appreciate an office that functions this way. What's waiting a bit longer, if needed, to know you (and others) will receive top care? Finally, (and most importantly) I have made a FULL recovery. I am SO glad I went through with surgery with Dr. Millstein. I am back to 8 shows a week with no pain.
RR
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is an excellent doctor and surgeon. He is very caring, friendly, attentive, and everything you need in a doctor who is about to perform surgery on your body. He took great care of me when I had to get shoulder surgery for my multiple dislocations. Now I am back to playing basketball with confidence in my shoulder. His staff is amazing too. I highly recommend Dr. Millstein if you have any injuries!
SN
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein is hands down the best doctor I've ever been to. His unique approach to sports medicine and Injuries is very refreshing. Will listen to every word you have to say and will always consider alternative options. Has sympathy for the pain his patients walk in with, which makes everybody feel at ease. Clean professional environment. I recommend Doc Millstein for anything from knees to ankles to shoulders to hips.
MF
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I would recommend Dr Millstein to EVERYBODY. I am a Krav Maga instructor and use my shoulder daily. My choice for a great doctor, was a must. When I dislocated my shoulder Dr. Millstein recommended multiple options prior to me having surgery. Dr. Millstein was very descriptive of the procedure, provided pictures of the surgery, explained the recovery period and honest time line to full recovery. The operating room was top notch and made me feel comfortable. After surgery, Dr. Millstein personally called me the following day to make sure I was doing well. The follow up from suggesting a Physical Therapist, and checking up on me during the recovery was EXCEPTIONAL. One year later, I am doing muscle-ups, sparring, and hand stand push-ups. My shoulder is stronger now than it was prior to surgery. If you are going to see any orthopedics specialist, Dr. Millstein is the BEST in LA.
KS
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I had a lovely appt with Dr. Millstein. Went in for a Frozen Shoulder. He is clearly knowledgeable and has a wonderful sense of humor. He knew exactly what to do and his mild manner helped to make the injections easier to withstand.
DI
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

- former high level athlete - baseball player - had shoulder surgery at the Kerlin jobe clinic. Found millstein : felt comfortable - with his prognosis. After surgery , several months, had a problem as it wasn't healing right and tough to walk- Acl reconstruction - Came to see him for follow up to discuss - he immediately placed it on me. I didn't follow treatment etc, actively taking notes- to protect him from litigation. Rather then offer to look at my knee. I had a surgery 18 months later- to fix the issues, he must have missed. Nice guy but more concerned about the dollars - then his work or patient satisfaction.
PG
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein was very eager to perform joint replacements (knee and shoulder) without adequately reviewing imaging reports with me. It seems that his scheduler (not a physician) provides him with information that he relies on without verification. In one case, his assistant (Marianne) told me that my MRI only showed arthritis when, in fact, it showed significant injuries from a recent fall. When I attempted to discuss it further her comment was, "I'm not going to argue with you." Both physicians that I saw for second opinions did not think that replacements were indicated at this time. I'm so glad that I did not move forward with this practice.
TS
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Forget the reviews skip this doctor!!!! Very very disappointing. It was suggested to me by a hospital doctor and a neurologist to see an orthopedic doctor. I chose Dr. Millstein myself based on reviews, and because of that waited over a month to see him. The issue is THEY KNEW I HAD A BACK AND NECK ISSUE (and serious numbness) and they made the appointment and then I waited yet another two hours when the day of finally arrived as he was overbooked (at least a few people had the exact same time appointment!) for absolutely nothing- the assistant brought in my mri put it up but he completely ignored it as Dr, Millstein asked if I was aware he was the wrong doctor. He is currently only seeing KNEE AND SHOULDER patients. Quelle joke!!! He immediately dismissed me and I asked if he was going to charge me anyway. He said yes!!!!! Amazing right???? Rip off the insurance company. Completely unethical. Angrily I decided to show him a knee injury. He had me go for an in house X-ray and said there was nothing he could do about this. Could it be he went to the wrong place years ago and took a hypocritic oath instead of hypocratic? I bet he charged my insurance a bundle for being the wrong ductir
ES
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

One an a half hours after I went to his office he saw me. This place is a mill they run as many people through here as possible. Went to discuss a shoulder problem in and out in about 6 minutes. Not even a fundamental X-ray. I am in the medical field, and it bothered the Doctor that I knew my way around the body and asked very specific questions. II urge anyone reading this review it for Dr. cannot spend the time to listen to you you get up and leave I wish I had.
DC
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD

by Mark on Mar 24th, 2015 It honestly takes a lot for me to write a bad review, I always try to see things from more than my prospective so I usually don't complain about much , but this experience really left a terrible taste in my mouth and I felt I needed to share to help avoid any other prospective patients falling for the same thing I did by reading some of these reviews, which BTW I now question the validity of. Read the bad reviews FIRST guys, you can see most of us have a common thread to our complains, but now I will share my experience. I am on Workers Comp, I had been trying to find a Dr who could really evaluate what was going on with my Lower Back , Wrist and Shoulder. After much searching I came across this person with such glowing reviews , completely ignoring the negative ones because the good ones sounded so good. My Nurse Case Manager made the appointment and confirmed that this Dr Millstein treats lower backs as well as other ailments, I was looking forward to meeting this Dr and all I can say is that the bad reviews I read were in fact more true than anything, nothing about the "positive" reviews was anywhere near present on this day. I came into the Dr's office where I was telling him my nightmare journey with Workers Comp and how I came to find him hoping he could help me. First thing he told me is that he does NOT do backs, which is not what me nor my nurse case manager was told. Secondly he said he no longer is going to be doing Workers Comp cases. Great so now what? Me and my nurse case manager both showed his the results of both my back and shoulder. My MRI of my lower back showed Degenerative Disc Disease and it had advanced in the last few years, it was causing me excruciating pain for weeks and two Dr's I had seen previously (both Ortho's btw) said I should not be working for 30 days and prescribed physical therapy . Unfortunately neither of those Dr were under my Workers Comp list of providers , hence I went looking for a Dr that really knew what he was doing. He took an Xray of my wrist and said nothing was wrong at all. Then looked at my MRI results of my shoulder (it clearly showed an injury) and he brushed it off as "no big deal" then moving along to my back , he said it showed some degeneration but that he had several other patients who were older than me and had many more ailments and were able to work and manage regardless. First of all, you cannot compare one patient with all the others, every patient should be tended to as an individual with their own concerns, not lumped into a category of "if they can do it so can you" . He said he didn't mean to diminish my ailments but he was releasing me back to work on full duty. I've been working 13 years for my current employer, I rarely take sick time or vacation so I am not a lazy person, if this was about me just wanting to take a "paid vacation" trust me, I have the vacation time to do it, the point was that I was in pain and I was injured and if I can't work then so be it, but when I go looking for help from a professional to give me a professional comprehensive exam I expect better. So he doesn't even do backs or spine yet he has the superiority to tell me that my back and shoulder were no big deal. I am in the process of finding another Dr at this point but I must let anyone who is reading that someone with such arrogance and ego should not be practicing medicine. Read the other reviews both good and bad, you will see common complaints from other patients. My two cents. Doctors Oath - "First do no harm" Update: my response to the Dr's reply to my previous post. Dr Millstein, you had an opportunity to make things right when I was in your office and had my MRI's in hand. Now it's too little too late . Someone like you does not deserve to carry a medical license in my opinion . If you really cared you would have done the right thing from the start. If anyone is reading this please take from my experience and stay away from this imbecile . Seriously one of the worst experiences with any medical provider.
PA
Read review on Yelp

Eric S. Millstein, MD