Eric S. Millstein, MD
Recovery and return to activity reviews
Page 3 of 3.
Back to these patient experiences →
53 written reviews
Highest rated first · Newest within each rating
I would recommend Dr Millstein to EVERYBODY. I am a Krav Maga instructor and use my shoulder daily. My choice for a great doctor, was a must. When I dislocated my shoulder Dr. Millstein recommended multiple options prior to me having surgery. Dr. Millstein was very descriptive of the procedure, provided pictures of the surgery, explained the recovery period and honest time line to full recovery. The operating room was top notch and made me feel comfortable. After surgery, Dr. Millstein personally called me the following day to make sure I was doing well. The follow up from suggesting a Physical Therapist, and checking up on me during the recovery was EXCEPTIONAL. One year later, I am doing muscle-ups, sparring, and hand stand push-ups. My shoulder is stronger now than it was prior to surgery. If you are going to see any orthopedics specialist, Dr. Millstein is the BEST in LA.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
Dr Millstein surgically repaired my ACL. I could not recommend anyone more highly. From my initial consult, through the surgery, and throughout the rehab process, he was always knowledgable, relatable and very supportive. I have since recommended him to family and friends, all of whom have had equally satisfying experiences. Without hesitation, he would be my first (and only) call in the future...
Eric S. Millstein, MD
So back on January 1, 2013 I fell while ice skating for the first time. It was extremely painful and my leg twisted strangely underneath my back. Sounds like it hurt? Yeah, to say the least it did. I'm not a complainer and passed it off as a reeeeeeallly bad sprain. January passed. February came and went. March came and went & I still had considerable pain just walking. Turns out I did a bit more than "just spraining" it. So I sought the professional evaluation of Dr. Millstein. I am glad I did, we did all the necessary testing and diagnostics. His professionalism is only exceeded by his wonderful personality. He provided a Physical Therapy script and as I write, my ankle is much better than it was a few weeks ago. Thank you!
Eric S. Millstein, MD
- former high level athlete - baseball player - had shoulder surgery at the Kerlin jobe clinic. Found millstein : felt comfortable - with his prognosis. After surgery , several months, had a problem as it wasn't healing right and tough to walk- Acl reconstruction - Came to see him for follow up to discuss - he immediately placed it on me. I didn't follow treatment etc, actively taking notes- to protect him from litigation. Rather then offer to look at my knee. I had a surgery 18 months later- to fix the issues, he must have missed. Nice guy but more concerned about the dollars - then his work or patient satisfaction.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
I chose Dr. Millstein based on Yelp reviews and also a friend of a friend who went to him before. Now after my experience with him I would definitely not go to him again. This review is for Knee Meniscus problems (partial tear) with surgery, he might be different/better in regards to other issues. With a partial tear I started getting increasing pain when playing Beach Volleyball for more than 1-2 hours or walking longer than 2-3 hours. First visit to him he did a decent look at my condition but was extremely quick and rather pushy to schedule a surgery for a meniscectomy. At that time I declined because I wanted to try physical therapy further and strengthen the knee first. Second visit few months later he still suggested surgery and since my problems were not notice-ably from physical therapy I agreed to the surgery. Dr. Millstein explicitly and clearly confirmed that the outcome of the surgery would either be no overall change or improvement of my condition, definitely not a degradation of the situation. It would take 1 month to get to 80%, 2 to 95% and 3-4 month to 100% back to previous knee performances. The surgery at LaPeer itself went pretty smooth and problem free, however 2 month later with regular physical therapy and home exercises I fee at best to be to be at 50%. Still problems with walking stairs and other basic movements. 6 months later (whole time PT) I still can't jog, run, jump or do any fast movement. Walking stairs is possible and slow, even weighted movements are ok. However any quick movements are a no go, basically 0% ability when it comes to any kind of sport. This is a serious degradation of my previous condition. I understand not every surgery will bring the expected results, but a surgery shouldn't make the condition way way worse than it was before. Last follow up around 6 months later with Dr. Millstein he simply says it takes time. Also of my previous ~70% of medial meniscus left (from prior first surgery) I now per Millstein have only 20/30% meniscus left. He removed so much of the meniscus that I have barely any left. 9 months later my knee swell up from 15 minutes walking and after MRI and a different Orthopedic Doctor I now am being confirmed with cartilage damaged on the bone at the area where I am missing the meniscus and have to get another surgery. The surgery Dr. Millstein performed on me made my overall knee condition worse 3-4 times than it was before. I wish I never got that surgery or went to a different Orthopedic who would have opted for a repair instead of remove approach. I will most likely need a full meniscus transplant thanks to that very soon which comes with a year of recovery time. If you also have meniscus problems, don't go to Dr. Millstein.
Eric S. Millstein, MD
