Eric S. Millstein, MD

Patient reviews

← Back to the clinician profile

649 written reviews

Highest rated first · Newest within each rating

I respect his medical care and especially, his "not rushing to surgery" care.
SK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is my orthopedic surgeon of choice for my own surgery coming up. I’m sure anyone reading this can imagine how important a shoulder surgery would be for me as a surgeon myself. I asked several colleagues for referrals, and all roads led to Dr. Millstein
DT
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Eric Milstein is comprehensively the definition of a great orthopedic surgeon: calm, confident, honest, responsive, caring, good listener, supportive , focused, present, and technically an expert in his surgical speciality! This is far more than just a good surgeon!!!
V
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein and his staff were friendly and professional. I felt in good hands and all my questions and concerns were addressed with patience.
LS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Milstein is incredibly thorough, compassionate and caring physician. I have already had him replace one knee and I’m about to have the other done and I couldn’t be more confident in his skill and my treatment in the past and upcoming!
CS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

He is compassionate.
AB
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is one of the most common doctors I’ve been to not only does he know what he’s doing but his warmth and understanding it’s quite unique
ML
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Millstein is great. Recommend him with no reservations.
KK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I fell on a treadmill that stopped while going around 6.8 mph on an 14.5 incline and slammed hard and fast onto a wood floor. I broke my shoulder, dislocated it, and caused a rotator tear. I waited several weeks for the appointment and drove from the Valley. This was a trek that seemed worth it. Now in retrospect was likely a fair amount of one reviews (questionable ratings). Dr Millstein is nice enough but that does not make a great doctor. He spent less than three minutes with me. There was almost no exam except for 'hold your arm out.' Then he announced the diagnosis of frozen shoulder and proceeded to offer me steroids. I had a tumor history so he then said I could not have this until I got clearance from my doctor. I appreciated that taking that caution, but I would also like to think an MD would know that Glios and brain tumors in this category are the only tumors that are exacerbated by steroids/Cortisones). You would think a doctor would know that. My neurotologist said as much. Additionally, I asked about a Cortisone shot vs steroids. First, he said no to the shot then he flip flopped. I want a doctor to tell me with absolution what I need. This should not be a pick and choose like a pair of shoes with a patient. This is why I drove out of my way. Additionally, he told me to call the doctor myself. I never heard of a doctor telling the patient to call and ask their doctor. Normal protocol is a staff member gets the doctors' info and then communicates with the doctor or gets them on the line with the doctor needing the information (I have a fair number of doctors in my family). I could have not bothered and said it's fine and just had the shot or meds, but I didn't. I was assured that I could be fit in the following week if I had to come back. Thanksgiving weekend was two days later so I had to wait until the following week. I proceeded to call five days after that visit only to be told it would be another two weeks. They offered me a slot that day but there was no way I could get there otherwise it was another two weeks. No accommodations were made and then it's another trip, visit, and more unnecessary nonsense in addition to weeks more pain, but I think it was a lesson learned because he is not the right doctor for me. I sent my info to a surgeon that treats top sports teams, and he offered a non-surgical procedure. Was this even mentioned in that 2.5-minute visit...nope! In conclusion: this doctor does not respect other peoples' time and seems a bit too speedy with the very limited offered care in the visit.
CC
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein and his staff are fantastic!
CK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein is a superstar! Fixed my fully torn rotator cuff 6 years ago and I'm doing yoga 5+ days a week. First choice for shoulder or knee problems.
N
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I have had some not so great experiences with trying to find a doctor that is great at what he does but can also balance the doctor patient relationship and Finally I have got it right .I have only just begun with this office but already I can tell it’s top notch , and at the same time there is a sense actual cari g about the patient …very rare these days for a sought after specialist .I feel like I’m in good hands now .
MK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Friendly, clean, waiting time not bad, GREAT Doctor and the BEST office staff ever! Parking sux :///
VM
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is the perfect doctor. He is an excellent surgeon, he is positive and optimistic, it’s obvious he cares about his patients and wants to educate them if they’re interested. It’s a pleasure to be in his presence. His staff are helpful, polite and friendly. It’s a great office.
EH
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Fantastic office; personal staff and the Dr is excellent
PS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

All very good. Office staff very friendly & well mannered.
DN
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein and his staff provide not just a very professional and caring experience and expertise, but they are all very kind, friendly and welcoming as well.
SM
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

I love dr Millstein and the entire staff at commons clinic. My only issue is the wait time. I would so appreciate if the appointment time could be honored closer to when it’s scheduled. Having said that I wouldn’t trade this dr for anyone else!
DF
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein provides clear advice, is very customer focused. It is a true pleasure visiting him, also because the staff is well trained an very respectful
NA
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein is the best, competent and truthful, if his expertise is not what you need he will tell you and recommend whom to see. Once again the best
GS
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr. Millstein is very caring, patient and knowledgeable. A true expert in his field. He explained in detail the source of my knee pain that was coming from my hip. He gave me an injection and delivered treatment options with clarity. I highly recommend him to anyone who suffers with knee, hip and back pain.
SA
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Efficient and knowledgeable staff and doctor
RB
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Everyone is friendly and knowledgeable. Dr. Millstein is a great doctor. I had a full knee replacement and I am very happy with the results!
JK
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD

Dr Millstein did an amazing job on my shoulder surgery. He’s very attentive, caring and explained every step of the way. He’s an exceptional doctor, I’m very thankful surgery went so smoothly.
TM
Google
Reviewer’s Google activity

Eric S. Millstein, MD