1. What problem is replacement intended to address?
AAOS describes hip replacement as an option for a damaged hip when pain and disability affect everyday life and other measures do not provide enough relief. The evaluation includes symptoms, examination, and imaging.
Explain what has changed in your day: sleep, walking, work, shoes and socks, or time with family. Ask which symptoms the surgeon expects replacement to improve and whether another condition might also be contributing. A clear diagnosis helps keep the decision focused. You want to understand why an operation is being recommended for you, rather than assuming that a difficult-looking X-ray settles the question by itself.
Sources: Total Hip Replacement
2. Which alternatives and timing choices remain reasonable?
AAHKS emphasizes the effect of symptoms on quality of life when discussing the decision to proceed. Its patient resource describes nonsurgical measures as part of the overall treatment discussion.
Bring a record of what you have tried, how long you tried it, and what changed. Ask what another treatment or a period of waiting is expected to accomplish. If you are already an appropriate surgical candidate, ask whether any proposed delay has a specific purpose. If your circumstances make recovery difficult now, discuss how the team would support that problem and how the plan would be reviewed. The decision should include your preferences, not just an available date.
Sources: Total Hip Replacement
3. What experience is most relevant to my hip?
AAHKS recommends combining several sources of information when choosing a surgeon, including professional information and a direct consultation. Board certification, additional training, and the fit between the practice and your problem can be useful things to verify.
Ask about experience with your type of operation and any feature that makes it more complex, such as previous surgery or unusual anatomy. If outcomes are discussed, ask how they are measured and which patients are included. There is no need to invent a score from star ratings or compare physicians by review volume. The goal is to understand relevant experience and whether the surgeon can explain a plan that fits you.
4. Why this approach, implant, or technology?
The surgical approach is the route used to reach the hip. Johns Hopkins explains that approach and implant decisions depend on several factors, including anatomy, bone health, activity, and the way the implant will be attached.
Ask why the surgeon recommends the proposed option and what alternatives they considered. If robotic assistance or a particular implant is discussed, ask what it changes in your case, what evidence supports that use, and whether it changes costs or follow-up. Avoid letting a brand or a smaller-incision claim substitute for the full conversation. Your surgeon should be able to describe the important tradeoffs in language you can use when comparing another opinion.
Sources: Hip Replacement Surgery
5. Which risks matter most for my health and history?
Hip replacement can have complications, including infection, blood clots, instability, and problems involving the implant or surrounding bone. AAOS explains that medical conditions can influence risk and preparation.
Ask which risks are most relevant to you and how the team tries to reduce and recognize them. Bring your medication list and tell the team about prior infections, clots, anesthesia problems, or previous operations. Ask who coordinates any medical assessment before surgery and obtain written medication instructions. A useful risk conversation connects a complication with a prevention and response plan; it is more informative than an assurance that complications are rare.
Sources: Total Hip Replacement
6. What does the recovery plan require at home?
Johns Hopkins’ recovery guidance emphasizes planning among the patient, family, and care team. Medical needs and support at home can influence discharge arrangements and recovery support.
Describe your stairs, bathroom, sleeping area, and the people available to help. Ask how the team will decide where you recover, what equipment you may need, and who will coordinate therapy. If you live alone, say so before surgery. Discuss driving, work duties, and transport to appointments as separate questions. Request practical goals and review points rather than relying on one universal recovery estimate or a date reported in a review.
Sources: Hip Replacement Recovery: Q&A with a Hip Specialist
7. What follow-up will protect the longer care relationship?
AAHKS notes the importance of a long-term follow-up plan for a hip replacement. Feeling well after the early recovery period does not make it unnecessary to understand future review arrangements.
Ask who handles wound questions, pain concerns, medication refills, and unexpected symptoms during the first weeks. Then ask how routine follow-up works later, including what records you should keep if you move or change insurance. Clarify the office-hours and after-hours contacts. If you are comparing practices, ask how information moves between the surgeon, primary care clinician, and therapist. You are choosing a care pathway as well as a person to perform an operation.
Sources: Total Hip Replacement
8. How should I weigh patient reviews and the consultation?
A patient account can make the experience of care feel more concrete. Look for details that matter to you: a careful explanation, respectful answers, a workable recovery plan, or help when something was difficult.
Check that the story actually describes hip replacement and the named clinician. Notice when it was written and how far along recovery had progressed. AAHKS cautions against relying on a single source when choosing a surgeon. Use reviews to prepare questions and compare the quality of the conversation you have yourself. They do not establish comparative complication rates, implant longevity, or who is the best surgeon for every person.
Make the most of your visit
Questions to bring to your consultation
Choose the questions that matter most to you. Bring them along, and ask us to explain anything that is unclear.
- What is replacement intended to improve, and could another problem be contributing?
- Which alternatives remain reasonable, and would waiting change the decision?
- What experience do you have with hips like mine?
- Why do you recommend this approach, implant, or technology?
- Which risks matter most in my case, and how will they be managed?
- What support, equipment, therapy, and transport would I need?
- Who handles urgent questions and long-term follow-up?
- How will we judge the outcome against the goals that matter to me?
Sources & further reading
- Total Hip ReplacementAmerican Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
- Total Hip ReplacementAmerican Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons
- Choosing the Right Hip Surgeon for YouAmerican Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons
- Hip Replacement SurgeryJohns Hopkins Medicine
- Hip Replacement Recovery: Q&A with a Hip SpecialistJohns Hopkins Medicine · Updated March 20, 2026
We use these medical sources to help explain your options and prepare you for a conversation with our team. Our guides feature our own clinicians; patient reviews describe individual experiences.



