﻿Published by Commons Clinic.

[Web version](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/page/2/)

Reviewer names are abbreviated. Patient reviews describe individual experiences. Review counts describe source records, not unique patients or clinical outcomes; the acquired snapshot may not include complete platform histories. Clinical education and patient accounts do not replace a consultation.

Eric S. Millstein, MD

# Consultations and first visits reviews

Page 2 of 2.

[Back to these patient experiences →](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/)

31 written reviews

Highest rated first · Newest within each rating

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:6vml_WU_LAR5EJOx_fcmFQ","format":"full"} -->

> Luckily I do not know Dr. Millstein from a patient perspective (knock wood).  However, as a physical therapist and owner of Evolution Physical Therapy, I have had the pleasure of working with many of his patients.  Over the years I have had the opportunity to work with many physicians and orthopedic surgeons and I can say with great confidence that Dr. Millstein is among the best.  If any of my family or I needed an orthopedic consultation, he would be the one we'd go to without hesitation.
>
> From a professional perspective, I appreciate that he does not rush into surgery which is a real breath of fresh air.  He encourages other conservative methods of treatment prior to surgery.  His diagnostic skills are great and all the patients we treat appreciate his bed-side manner.  Without exception, every patient feels that Dr Millstein genuinely cares for their health and takes time to explain procedures and answer all questions.  This fact alone sets him far above many other clinicians.
>
> When surgery is in fact indicated, his skills are remarkable.  His patients recover very quickly from surgeries and outcomes are exceptional.  He is also an active physician and he understands the mentality of patients who are eager to return to sports and active lifestyles.
>
> If you are in need of an orthopedic consultation, do not hesitate to go see Dr Millstein.  You owe it to your body!

D. F.

Rating: 5/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 1/22/14

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=6vml_WU_LAR5EJOx_fcmFQ&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"trustindex:165230599","format":"full"} -->

> Mine was a very mixed experience with this orthopedist and staff.    I found Dr. Millstien on the internet.    I’ve been treated several times in his offices for a very typical joint issue, no surgery.
>
> His offices are very conveniently located.    Each was very clean with absolutely no wait times.     It is really comfortable in the beautiful waiting areas; both waiting areas were nearly always empty on all of my visits.    My first impression of Dr. Millstien was that he was a nice guy.
>
> But although my first visit was fine, I get a strong sense something is “off” with this organization.
>
> My second visit was OK, but I’ve noticed that this doctor’s bedside manner seems caring at first, but later surfaces as quite arrogant, condescending and “superior to you.”    Honestly, he comes off making it clear that he is doing you a favor by treating you.
>
> Although he called me with test results, he recommended a very cookie-cutter approach -- cortizone “for the pain” -- which I resisted as I knew it to be a short-term, band-aid fix.    My pain had gone.      I succeeded in leading him (via many phone calls with one helpful nurse) to a more sophisticated treatment used by the top guys.     I would have expected him to have led this discussion and options with me right off the bat since it is known that cortizone can have negative side effects.   Still...no big deal.
>
> But what followed were excruciating, unnecessary problems with his poorly trained staff -- they are incompetent, unhelpful and really don’t seem to care that a patient is calling because that patient needs assistance.    In my case, I only needed a procedure code typically required by insurance -- just a number!     Ironically, they answer the phone with “How may I help you?” yet cannot or will not fulfill that promise.
>
> One staffer refused to provide the code, yelled at me and made me feel as if my insurance company’s need was a real bother to her and her co-workers.    What the very rude and condescending staff member finally provided....... was still wrong simply because she refused to listen to my request.    Her behavior was unacceptable.    I ended up getting the needed code from the doctor in person on my final visit -- it took him less than 10 seconds to provide it.
>
> I really gave this place a chance because it is so convenient and their internet website marketing really pulled me in.    But I will NOT return here and certainly would NOT consider surgery with this organization should I need it.      Lesson learned -- 1) don’t pic a doc off the internet just because he is close.     2) the way the staff treat patients starts at the top of the organization, trickling down from the attitude of the guy whose name is on the door.
>
> There are hundreds of great orthopedic guys with professional, caring, service-oriented staffs in Los Angeles.      Now I am reminded why the best orthopedists have the busiest waiting rooms!

M.

Rating: 5/5 · Source: Google · Date: Sep 1, 2013

[Reviewer’s Google activity](https://www.google.com/maps/contrib/103951554124979946392/place/ChIJt04grlG5woARykBaakD_dF8)

Source link type: reviewer place

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:HL0B14l5P7DIayHq9wFIjQ","format":"full"} -->

> Today I received probably the worst news an athlete could have expected on a first visit - a potential Rotator Cuff tear (needs further diagnosis via MRI). The positive is I felt I was dealing with a total professional, nice, human who understood that, though in my 40's, I am still a competitive athlete who just wants to continue doing what I love. No lectures, no obvious impatience with my chosen lifestyle, etc.
>
> He introduced himself as Eric (i of couse said nice to meet you Dr....) and then walked me through what he saw at this point in my examination - explained on his iPad (yes the dude is tech savvy) how the rotator cuff is comprised, its function, and why I am feeling the pain I do. In the midst of all this potential bad news, I felt comforted, his staff was top notch, facilities clean etc...
>
> Yes I have an MRI to go - maybe surgery (maybe not!!!) but all I can say is if you are in the same boat I am, don't muck around, call his office, go see him - then make your decisions based on what you learn. Oh and though I saw him in Beverly Hills I was in and out in an hour... Lovely.

J. H.

Rating: 5/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 4/9/12

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=HL0B14l5P7DIayHq9wFIjQ&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:TpN2-eA5OAcFzzXq-Vjs7g","format":"full"} -->

> My 11 year old son had been complaining about knee pain for a few weeks, and his pediatrician recommended an orthopedist we weren't happy with from a previous visit (we waited almost two hours to see him, while my son was in pain with a broken wrist). I needed to find a good doc, so I did what I always do... Checked in with Yelp!  When I saw Dr. Millstein's listing I remembered him from two years ago when I had taken my daughter to his old office in century city, and at the time thought he was terrific! Very professional and very personable at the same time.  I remember thinking, at that time, that I needed to remember his name, but alas, life gets hectic... Bottom line, I  called and got an appointment for my son for a few days later.  The office has you fill in paperwork at home (big time saver!) and when we got to his beautiful new office, we were taken in within about 5 - 10 minutes.  The office staff were all very friendly, and seeing Dr. Millstein reminded me of why I was so happy on the first visit, years ago. He has a great personal manner and my son was immediately comfortable.  The Dr. took his time in speaking with my son, learning the progression, and doing a complete physical exam.  When he gave his diagnosis, he took out his new iPad to show my son an animated 3-D image of the knee and explained how the knee works and exactly why his was hurting.  My son was very impressed and so was I.  We are a very active family and have seen too many orthopedists here in L.A. Until now, I haven't been impressed by anyone like I am with Dr. Millstein.  He clearly knows his craft very well! My son will be starting physical therapy next week, and we'll check in with Dr Millstein in a couple of weeks.  It's good to know that my son's knees are in good hands, and Dr Millstein's number is now programmed into my phone!

P. B.

Rating: 5/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 6/2/11

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=TpN2-eA5OAcFzzXq-Vjs7g&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:aRbfd5vg23ocEI4UqRo-8A","format":"full"} -->

> Mine was a very mixed experience with this orthopedist and staff.    I found Dr. Millstien on the internet.    I've been treated several times in his offices for a very typical joint issue, no surgery.
>
> His offices are very conveniently located.    Each was very clean with absolutely no wait times.     It is really comfortable in the beautiful waiting areas; both waiting areas were nearly always empty on all of my visits.    My first impression of Dr. Millstien was that he was a nice guy.
>
> But although my first visit was fine, I get a strong sense something is "off" with this organization.
>
> My second visit was OK, but I've noticed that this doctor's bedside manner seems caring at first, but later surfaces as quite arrogant, condescending and "superior to you."    Honestly, he comes off making it clear that he is doing you a favor by treating you.
>
> Although he called me with test results, he recommended a very cookie-cutter approach -- cortizone "for the pain" -- which I resisted as I knew it to be a short-term, band-aid fix.    My pain had gone.      I succeeded in leading him (via many phone calls with one helpful nurse) to a more sophisticated treatment used by the top guys.     I would have expected him to have led this discussion and options with me right off the bat since it is known that cortizone can have negative side effects.   Still...no big deal.
>
> But what followed were excruciating, unnecessary problems with his poorly trained staff -- they are incompetent, unhelpful and really don't seem to care that a patient is calling because that patient needs assistance.    In my case, I only needed a procedure code typically required by insurance -- just a number!     Ironically, they answer the phone with "How may I help you?" yet cannot or will not fulfill that promise.
>
> One staffer refused to provide the code, yelled at me and made me feel as if my insurance company's need was a real bother to her and her co-workers.    What the very rude and condescending staff member finally provided....... was still wrong simply because she refused to listen to my request.    Her behavior was unacceptable.    I ended up getting the needed code from the doctor in person on my final visit -- it took him less than 10 seconds to provide it.
>
> I really gave this place a chance because it is so convenient and their internet website marketing really pulled me in.    But I will NOT return here and certainly would NOT consider surgery with this organization should I need it.      Lesson learned -- 1) don't pic a doc off the internet just because he is close.     2) the way the staff treat patients starts at the top of the organization, trickling down from the attitude of the guy whose name is on the door.
>
> There are hundreds of great orthopedic guys with professional, caring, service-oriented staffs in Los Angeles.      Now I am reminded why the best orthopedists have the busiest waiting rooms!

F. r.

Rating: 2/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 8/31/13

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=aRbfd5vg23ocEI4UqRo-8A&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:-YhZTzopdERVunHHQ2b8qg","format":"full"} -->

> The 1980s called, they want their God complex back.
> Please note that most of these 5 star reviews that I was also sucked into are all approximately ""one year ago"". So one year ago he had a rash of almost 25 people that couldn't say more fabulous things about him. Certainly not my experience. To start- the electronic data check in process is predatorily  intrusive... It feels like they're feeding all the data into a central WBAN system. Upon arrival, after they were finally pleased with all my signatures and disclosures, 10 minutes passes while he's standing outside door loudly socializing  with his assistants about his internet purchases. When he finally walks in and I ask him if he's going to buy the shoes, he gives me a snotty  "I don't know, maybe". Contemptuous glare, zero apology.
> He then went on to behave like a slovenly teenager, angry that I had to nerve to point out I was running late. He made it exceedingly clear that he could care less about helping my painful medical situation and even interrupted the consultation to argue with me about how he had a right to be late & that I should go elsewhere. Arrogant, rude, disrespectful & made us miss the deadline for funding our Spacex ipo.

T. T.

Rating: 1/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 6/29/26

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=-YhZTzopdERVunHHQ2b8qg&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

<!-- review: {"id":"yelp:rYZw_VAokSPz_g9Rk1F-FQ","format":"full"} -->

> I chose Dr. Millstein based on Yelp reviews and also a friend of a friend who went to him before.
>
> Now after my experience with him I would definitely not go to him again. This review is for Knee Meniscus problems (partial tear) with surgery, he might be different/better in regards to other issues.
> With a partial tear I started getting increasing pain when playing Beach Volleyball for more than 1-2 hours or walking longer than 2-3 hours.
>
> First visit to him he did a decent look at my condition but was extremely quick and rather pushy to schedule a surgery for a meniscectomy. At that time I declined because I wanted to try physical therapy further and strengthen the knee first.
>
> Second visit few months later he still suggested surgery and since my problems were not notice-ably from physical therapy I agreed to the surgery.
>
> Dr. Millstein explicitly and clearly confirmed that the outcome of the surgery would either be no overall change or improvement of my condition, definitely not a degradation of the situation.
> It would take 1 month to get to 80%, 2 to 95% and 3-4 month to 100% back to previous knee performances.
>
> The surgery at LaPeer itself went pretty smooth and problem free, however 2 month later with regular physical therapy and home exercises I fee at best to be to be at 50%. Still problems with walking stairs and other basic movements.
> 6 months later (whole time PT) I still can't jog, run, jump or do any fast movement. Walking stairs is possible and slow, even weighted movements are ok. However any quick movements are a no go, basically 0% ability when it comes to any kind of sport.
>
> This is a serious degradation of my previous condition.
> I understand not every surgery will bring the expected results, but a surgery shouldn't make the condition way way worse than it was before.
>
> Last follow up around 6 months later with Dr. Millstein he simply says it takes time.
>
> Also of my previous ~70% of medial meniscus left (from prior first surgery) I now per Millstein have only 20/30% meniscus left.
> He removed so much of the meniscus that I have barely any left.
>
> 9 months later my knee swell up from 15 minutes walking and after MRI and a different Orthopedic Doctor I now am being confirmed with cartilage damaged on the bone at the area where I am missing the meniscus and have to get another surgery.
>
> The surgery Dr. Millstein performed on me made my overall knee condition worse 3-4 times than it was before.
> I wish I never got that surgery or went to a different Orthopedic who would have opted for a repair instead of remove approach.
> I will most likely need a full meniscus transplant thanks to that very soon which comes with a year of recovery time.
>
> If you also have meniscus problems, don't go to Dr. Millstein.

M. R.

Rating: 1/5 · Source: Yelp · Date: 4/11/16

[Read review on Yelp](https://yelp.com/biz/eric-millstein-md-santa-monica?hrid=rYZw_VAokSPz_g9Rk1F-FQ&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=biz_post_share&l=en_US)

Source link type: verified permalink

Attributed clinician: Eric S. Millstein, MD

<!-- /review -->

[← Previous](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/) Page 2 of 2



## Complete review collection

[Read all 31 written reviews in this collection](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/all.md)

## Review pages in Markdown

Previous: [Previous review page](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/index.md)

Next: This is the last review page.

- [Page 1](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/index.md)
- [Page 2](https://commonsclinic.com/review-topics/consultation/eric-millstein/page/2/index.md)

## Publisher & attribution

Commons Clinic Reviews is operated by Commons Clinic. This website is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Google, Zocdoc, or Yelp.

Google, Google Maps, and Google Business Profile are trademarks of Google LLC. Zocdoc and the Zocdoc logo are trademarks of Zocdoc, Inc. Yelp and the Yelp logo are registered trademarks of Yelp Inc. All third-party names and logos belong to their respective owners and identify the original review sources.

© 2026 Commons Clinic. All rights reserved.
